Cart 0
The Culture of Saving in South Africa
South Africa has a unique dual economy when it comes to saving. On one side, we have the formal banking sector with its digital apps and interest rates. On the other, we have the vibrant, community-driven world of Stokvels, which manages an estimated R50 billion annually. When you are building an emergency fund—that crucial stash of cash for when life goes wrong—which vehicle is best?
The Case for the Stokvel
Stokvels are deeply rooted in the philosophy of Ubuntu. They are savings clubs where members contribute a fixed amount monthly.
Pros:
- Social Discipline: The pressure to not let the group down is a powerful motivator. You are far less likely to skip a contribution when Aunty Thandi is watching.
- High Yields (Sometimes): Some investment stokvels pool money to buy property or bulk groceries, generating returns that beat inflation.
- Community Support: Burial stokvels provide emotional and financial support during bereavement that a bank account cannot replicate.
Cons:
- Liquidity Risk: This is the big one for emergency funds. In a rotating stokvel, you get paid out when it’s your turn. If your car breaks down in March but your payout is in November, the money doesn’t help you.
- Security: While many use bank accounts now, cash-based stokvels are targets for crime. There is also the risk of mismanagement or fraud within the group.
The Case for the Bank Savings Account
Specifically, we are talking about high-interest savings or money market accounts (like TymeBank’s GoalSave or Capitec’s savings plans).
Pros:
- Liquidity: You can access your money immediately (or within 24 hours). This is essential for an emergency fund.
- Safety: Your money is guaranteed (up to a limit) and safe from theft.
- Interest: Digital banks are offering competitive rates (some up to 10% or 11% depending on the term), which is decent risk-free growth.
Cons:
- Ease of Access: Paradoxically, because it’s easy to get the money, it’s easy to spend it on non-emergencies (like a Black Friday sale).
- Inflation: Standard savings accounts often offer interest rates lower than inflation, meaning your money loses purchasing power over time.
The Hybrid Strategy
For most South Africans, the best approach is a mix.
1. The True Emergency Fund: Keep 1 to 3 months of expenses in a high-interest bank account. This is for immediate crises (medical, mechanical, job loss). It must be instantly accessible.
2. The Goal Fund: Use a Stokvel for planned expenses. If you know you need money for December holidays or January school uniforms, a Stokvel is perfect. The forced discipline ensures the money is there when the specific time comes.
Conclusion
Don’t view it as an “either/or” choice. Respect the cultural and disciplinary power of the Stokvel, but acknowledge the utility of the formal banking sector. For an emergency fund, cash in the bank is king. For building community wealth and disciplined saving for specific goals, the Stokvel remains a powerful tool in the South African financial toolkit.
